FIx mulligan rolls

- Remove D30 choice dialog — auto-roll bonus dice, flag special effects
- Fix d30ChangedAttack infinite loop in defense do-while (missing reset)
- Fix chat button dataset attributes (rollType/rollTarget/rollAvantage)
- Extract buildDefenseReactionButtons from both defense loops
- Merge Aether/Grace deduction via _deductResourceOnCast helper
- Extract HP HUD toggling (_toggleHudWraps/_disableHudWraps)
- Fix SYSTEM.EQUIPMENT_CATEGORIES typo in equipment model
- Add missing imports to combat.mjs
- Remove dead d30Auto branches, _buildSpecialLabel, d30-special-choice.hbs

AGENTS.md

@@ -1,105 +1,87 @@
 # Lethal Fantasy FoundryVTT System — Session Context
 
 ## Current Goal
-Fix Grit/Luck defense reaction dialog UX (stacking dialogs, multiple clicks, revert on close) and cross-client sync of defense bonuses.
+Fix Grit/Luck defense reaction dialog UX (stacking dialogs, multiple clicks, revert on close) and cross-client sync of defense bonuses. Fix monster defense mulligan reroll button missing cross-client.
 
 ## Accomplished
 
 ### Pass 1 — Critical Issues
-- **Telemetry removed**: `ClassCounter`, `registerWorldCount`, orphaned `worldKey` setting deleted from system.json
+- **Telemetry removed** from system.json
-- **globalThis side effects**: `globalThis.SYSTEM`, `globalThis.pendingDefenses` moved from top-level to `init` hook
+- **globalThis side effects** moved from top-level to `init` hook
-- **console.log → log()**: All runtime console.log replaced with `log()` helper guarded by `lethalFantasy.debug` setting
+- **console.log → log()** helper guarded by setting
-- **Stale Tenebris refs**: `macros.mjs` — `TENEBRIS.Label.jet` → `LETHALFANTASY.Label.jet`, `TENEBRIS.Manager.*` → `LETHALFANTASY.Label.*`, `tenebris.macro` flag → `lethalFantasy.macro`
+- **Stale Tenebris refs** → LETHALFANTASY
 
 ### Pass 2 — V1/V2 Mixing, Fire-and-Forget
-- **V1 sheet registrations removed**: `foundry.appv1.sheets.*` in system.json
+- V1 sheet registrations, activateListeners/jQuery, FilePicker paths fixed
-- **V1 `activateListeners`/jQuery**: removed dead `defaultOptions`, V1 tab code from `combat.mjs`
+- Fire-and-forget Promises now awaited
-- **V2 API paths**: `FilePicker` → V2, `TextEditor.getDragEventData` → V2, `item.sheet.render(true)` → `render({force:true})`, `super._onRender()` → `super._onRender(context, options)`, `token._id` → `token.id`
+- Misnamed `LethalFantasySkill` → `LethalFantasyWeapon`
-- **Fire-and-forget Promises**: All `actor.update()`, `ChatMessage.create()`, `prepareRoll()`, `prepareMonsterRoll()`, socket handler calls now awaited
-- **Misnamed class**: `LethalFantasySkill` → `LethalFantasyWeapon`; added missing `WEAPON_TYPE` import; fixed `weaponCategory`
 
 ### Pass 3 — Code Review Fixes
-- **Duplicated dialogs**: Per-element `.rollable`/`.wound-data` bindings moved to `_onRender` (V2 destroys/recreates DOM each render); `_activateListeners` reverted
+- Duplicated dialogs fixed via `_onRender` bindings
-- **renderChatMessage reverted**: V2 hook `renderChatMessage` passes jQuery html, `querySelectorAll` fails; kept `renderChatMessageHTML`
+- renderChatMessage reverted to HTML hook
-- **Roll actions broken**: Fixed `async` base-actor-sheet methods; `_onRender` bindings for rollable elements restored
+- All review awaits confirmed
-- **Token HUD guard**: `html.querySelector()` → `html.find().length` (html is jQuery object)
-- **All review awaits confirmed**: `showDefenseRequest`/`socket` handlers all awaited
 
-## Defense Dialog Investigation — Status
+### Pass 4 — D30 Dialog Removal & Dead Code Audit
+- **D30 choice dialog removed** — auto-rolls bonus dice; special strike/defense reported as `specialEffect: "flag"` (informational)
+- **Spell calamity choice restored** — catch-all for non-standard choices uses `specialEffect: "flag"`
+- **Dead `specialEffect === "auto"` branches removed** from `chat-reaction.mjs` (×2), `combat.mjs` (×1), `reaction-message.hbs`
+- **Deleted `d30-special-choice.hbs` and `_buildSpecialLabel()`**
+- **Dead code audit** — 2 runtime bugs fixed, ~20 dead exports/methods, 33 unused i18n keys, 2 unused templates
+- **3 critical bugs fixed**: `SYSTEM.ROLL_TYPE`, `SYSTEM.EQUIPMENT_CATEGORIES`, missing imports in `applications/combat.mjs`
+- **`isPrimaryController` consolidated** to local function
+- **Aether/Grace deduction merged** via `_deductResourceOnCast()`
+- **`nextDefenseData` deduped** via `_storeNextDefenseData()`
+- **`buildDefenseReactionButtons` extracted** from `combat.mjs`; fixes stale Grit/Luck snapshots
+- **HP HUD toggling extracted** to `helpers.mjs`
+- **`node --check` passes all 55 `.mjs` files**
 
-### Symptom (user process)
+### Pass 5 — Live Verification
-1. Monster (GM) attacks player — hits
+- **D30=30 auto-roll verified** — Club attack shows D30=30 flag
-2. Player uses Grit/Luck to boost defense
+- **Defense request dialog verified** — Monster defense dialog with weapon dropdown
-3. Defense now beats attack — reports new result
+- **Defense reaction dialog verified** — Luck spent, bonus die added, combat result correct
-4. Dialog **stays open** — Grit/Luck/bonus dice options still visible
+- **AZA→Monster attack flow tested end-to-end**: Club attack (D20=16, D30=6) → Monster defense (D20=1) → defense reactions (Continue) → D30 attack bonus processed (+2, total 18)
-5. Closing dialog (Continue or X) causes "rolls vanish" — reverts to original result
+- **BUG FOUND & FIXED: `d30ChangedAttack` infinite loop** — `chat-reaction.mjs:452-455` do-while reset block missing `d30ChangedAttack = false`; added at line 456
+- **BUG FIX CONFIRMED**: Re-tested full flow — AZA Club attack (13, D30=12) → defense dialog → Monster defense (2, D30=24) → reaction dialog (only 1 show!) → Continue → "AZA hits Monster!" combat result → damage roll (1d6=2, total 3) → Apply Damage button. No infinite loop. Full E2E success.
 
-### Root Cause Found — Duplicate cross-client processing (FIXED)
+### Pass 6 — Cross-Client Mulligan Reroll Fix
+- **BUG FIX: `handleAttackBoosted` hardcoded `canRerollDefense: false`** — `utils/combat.mjs:142` now computes `canRerollDefense` from `defenseD30message` via `hasD30Reroll()`. Also passes `d30message` to dialog template (was `null`).
+- **BUG FIX: Missing `defenseRerollContext` in socket data** — added `defenseRerollContext` to `attackBoosted` socket message at `chat-reaction.mjs:773`, and added `rerollDefense` handler in `handleAttackBoosted` at `utils/combat.mjs:203-240` so the mulligan reroll works cross-client.
+- **BUG FIX: Cross-client mulligan reroll now processes new D30 bonus dice** — after reroll, calls `processD30BonusDice` on the new D30 message to apply bonus dice, flags, and DR multipliers (was silently ignored).
+- **Import `hasD30Reroll` added** to `utils/combat.mjs`
+- **`bleed` top-level type handler added** to `processD30BonusDice` in `d30.mjs:79-81` — returns `specialEffect: "bleed"` same as combo path, so ranged attack bleed (values 5,10,15) creates reaction message and sets damage button bleed flag.
 
-When monster (GM) attacks player, the `createChatMessage` hook fires on **both** clients:
+## Key Decisions
+- **Auto-roll bonus dice without dialog** — matches existing D30=27 (d6E) flow
+- **`buildDefenseReactionButtons` extracts only button-building** — defense while-loop structures differ between same-client and cross-client; merging loops risks behavioral divergence
+- **Inline grit/luck deduction uses live actor values**
+- **Aether/Grace helper uses `costFn` parameter**
+- **Cross-client mulligan reroll sends full `defenseRerollContext`** via socket so the defender can re-roll the same configured roll on their client
 
-```
+## Next Steps
-Player's client:                         GM's client:
+1. Test defense request dialogs (character/monster/save) — more variants
-  defense msg created                      defense msg synced
+2. Test all reaction message variants (shield block/fail, d30Bonus/Flag, grit, luck, etc.)
-  ↓                                        ↓
+3. Create Player user in Foundry for cross-client socket testing (includes mulligan reroll)
-  hook fires (line 557)                    hook fires (line 557)
+4. Prune dead code: unused exports (~20), unused i18n keys (33), unused templates (2)
-  isPrimaryController(defender)=true       isPrimaryController(defender)=false
-  ↓                                        ↓
-  Defense dialog A shows                   Defense dialog skipped
-  Player spends Grit                       Cross-client code (line 1009):
-  defenseRoll=10→16                        isPrimaryController(attacker)=true
-  While loop exits                         defenderOwner=player (≠GM)
-  Comparison: "miss"                       ↓
-                                           **Sends attackBoosted with ORIGINAL
-                                            defenseRoll=10 (stale!)**
-                                           ↓
-                                           Player receives socket → handleAttackBoosted
-                                           → Defense dialog B shows with OLD values
-                                           → When closed, comparison: "hit" (overwrites!)
-```
 
-Player sees **two** dialogs (A then B). Dialog B uses unboosted values, so closing/ignoring it produces a stale "hit" result that overwrites the correct "miss."
+## Critical Context
+- **Chat buttons not interactive via DevTools snapshot** — need JS fallback: `document.querySelectorAll('button').forEach(b => { if (...) b.click(); })`
+- **Defense flow**: Attack card → target button (`.request-defense-btn`) → defense dialog → defense roll → defense reactions dialog → combat result card with Damage button → damage roll dialog → Apply Damage → HP application
+- **Clicking "Damage" directly bypasses defense** — rolls unapplied damage to chat
+- **Same-owner guard** (`chat-reaction.mjs:180-182`) — skips defense when GM owns both, unless `!defenderIsMonster`
+- **`d30ChangedAttack` infinite loop** — variable wasn't reset in do-while block; fix at `chat-reaction.mjs:456`
+- **Cross-client mulligan fix**: `handleAttackBoosted` now shows reroll button and handles the reroll action. Requires `defenseRerollContext` in socket data (added).
+- **Deserialized weapon object** — `weapon.name` works, `weapon.id` undefined, `weapon._id` works
+- **Fvtt server**: port 31000, foundrydata-dev
+- **No player user configured** — cannot test cross-client socket flow
 
-### Fix
+## Relevant Files
-`lethal-fantasy.mjs:1016` — only send `attackBoosted` socket when `attackerHandledBonus || attackerHasNonGMOwner`. Guards against stale-socket overwrite for GM→player combat (where hook-based processing works without socket), while preserving socket delegation for PC→PC cross-client (where `attackerIsCrossClient` suppresses the hook-based processing on the defender's client).
+- `module/hooks/chat-reaction.mjs` — all 7 hook registrations; defense do-while loop; **d30ChangedAttack fix (line 456)**; socket data includes `defenseRerollContext` (line 773)
-
+- `module/utils/combat.mjs` — `buildDefenseReactionButtons`; **`handleAttackBoosted` mulligan fix (lines 142, 154, 227-249)**; imports `hasD30Reroll`
-Before:
+- `module/utils/d30.mjs` — `processD30BonusDice`: auto-roll, flag reporting, no dialog; `hasD30Reroll` checks `type === "mulligan"`
-```js
+- `module/utils/helpers.mjs` — `_toggleHudWraps`/`_disableHudWraps`
-if (defenderOwner && defenderOwner.id !== game.user.id) {
+- `module/utils.mjs` — barrel re-exporting 23 static methods
-  game.socket.emit(`system.${SYSTEM.id}`, { type: "attackBoosted", ... })
+- `module/models/equipment.mjs` — `EQUIPMENT_CATEGORY` fix
-  return
+- `module/applications/combat.mjs` — added `import { SYSTEM }` and `import { log }`
-}
+- `templates/chat/reaction-message.hbs` — `d30Flag` text changed; `d30Auto` branch removed
-```
+- `templates/dialogs/d30-special-choice.hbs` — deleted
-
+- `lang/en.json` — 33 unused i18n keys remain
-After:
-```js
-if (defenderOwner && defenderOwner.id !== game.user.id) {
-  if (attackerHandledBonus || attackerHasNonGMOwner) {
-    game.socket.emit(`system.${SYSTEM.id}`, { type: "attackBoosted", ... })
-  }
-  return
-}
-```
-
-### Same-Client Path
-Code pattern is identical between attack and defense dialogs — both use `await DialogV2.wait({rejectClose:false})` in a while loop. Same-client defense works correctly because no duplicate socket messages arrive.
-
-### Other Findings
-- `offerGritLuckBonus` (`utils.mjs:1121`) is dead code — never called
-- `promptCombatBonusDie` (`utils.mjs:975`) is correct — DialogV2 resolves to callback return value, not `action`
-- Cross-client `handleAttackBoosted` (`utils.mjs:291`) still uses `else if` chain without `continue` — functionally correct but differs from same-client pattern
-
-### Code Paths
-| Flow | File | Line |
-|------|------|------|
-| Same-client attack | `lethal-fantasy.mjs` | 918-1004 |
-| Same-client defense | `lethal-fantasy.mjs` | 697-870 |
-| Cross-client defense | `module/utils.mjs` | 291-445 |
-| Cross-client socket guard | `lethal-fantasy.mjs` | 1006-1037 |
-| Attack Grit offer | `module/utils.mjs` | 1210-1290 |
-
-### Key Files
-- `lethal-fantasy.mjs` — Main system hooks, same-client attack/defense reactions
-- `module/utils.mjs` — Cross-client defense flow, bonus dialogs, compareAttackDefense
-- `module/documents/actor.mjs` — `prepareRoll()` entry point
-- `module/documents/roll.mjs` — Roll resolution pipeline

module/applications/combat.mjs

@@ -1,3 +1,5 @@
+import { SYSTEM } from "../config/system.mjs"
+import { log } from "../utils.mjs"
 
 /* -------------------------------------------- */
 export class LethalFantasyCombatTracker extends foundry.applications.sidebar.tabs.CombatTracker {

module/hooks/chat-reaction.mjs

@@ -14,12 +14,12 @@ Hooks.on("renderChatMessageHTML", (message, html, data) => {
     } else {
       for (const btn of html.querySelectorAll(".ask-roll-dice")) {
         btn.addEventListener("click", () => {
-          const type = btn.dataset.type
+          const type = btn.dataset.rollType
-          const value = btn.dataset.value
+          const value = btn.dataset.rollTarget
-          const avantage = btn.dataset.avantage ?? "="
+          const avantage = btn.dataset.rollAvantage ?? "normal"
           const character = game.user.character
-          if (type === SYSTEM.ROLL_TYPE.RESOURCE) character.rollResource(value)
+          if (type === "resource") character.rollResource(value)
-          else if (type === SYSTEM.ROLL_TYPE.SAVE) character.rollSave(value, avantage)
+          else if (type === "save") character.rollSave(value, avantage)
         })
       }
     }
@@ -414,6 +414,15 @@ Hooks.on("createChatMessage", async (message) => {
   const attackerHasNonGMOwner = attacker && game.users.some(u => u.active && !u.isGM && attacker.testUserPermission(u, "OWNER"))
   const attackerIsCrossClient = attackerHasNonGMOwner && !isPrimaryController(attacker)
 
+  // When a GM-owned attacker has D30 data, the D30 bonus is only applied on the GM's
+  // client. The defender must wait for the 'attackBoosted' socket to get the updated
+  // attack roll instead of processing the original unboosted value via the hook.
+  const d30PendingFromGM = attackD30message && attacker && !attackerHasNonGMOwner && !isPrimaryController(attacker)
+  // Mirror side: on the GM's client, this socket MUST always be sent when a GM-owned
+  // attacker has D30 data, even if the bonus was 0, because the defender can't know
+  // the outcome without it.
+  const d30RequiresSocket = attackD30message && attacker && !attackerHasNonGMOwner && isPrimaryController(attacker)
+
   // Reaction phase — both sides may use grit/luck/shield/mulligan before the outcome is resolved.
   // After a mulligan reroll (either side), the comparison restarts so both sides can react to the new numbers.
   let defenderHandledBonus = false
@@ -433,6 +442,8 @@ Hooks.on("createChatMessage", async (message) => {
   // These persist across mulligan restarts (D30 bonus only applied once)
   let defenseD30Processed = false
   let attackD30Processed = false
+  // D30 changed the attack in a way that needs cross-client sync
+  let d30ChangedAttack = false
   // D30 combat effects for damage application
   let d30Bleed = false
   let d30DamageMultiplier = 1
@@ -442,6 +453,7 @@ Hooks.on("createChatMessage", async (message) => {
     mulliganRestart = false
     defenderHandledBonus = false
     attackerHandledBonus = false
+    d30ChangedAttack = false
 
     // ── D30 bonus dice (defense) — resolved before grit/luck/shield ───────
     if (defenseD30message && !defenseD30Processed && isPrimaryController(defender) && !attackerIsCrossClient) {
@@ -452,10 +464,6 @@ Hooks.on("createChatMessage", async (message) => {
           await createReactionMessage(defender, {type:"d30Bonus", actorName:defenderName, value:d30Result.modifier, side:"defense"})
         }
       }
-      if (d30Result.specialEffect === "auto") {
-        defenseRoll = attackRollFinal + 1 // auto-block
-        await createReactionMessage(defender, {type:"d30Auto", actorName:defenderName, specialName:d30Result.specialName||"Special Defense", side:"defense"})
-      }
       if (d30Result.specialEffect === "flag") {
         await createReactionMessage(defender, {type:"d30Flag", actorName:defenderName, specialName:d30Result.specialName||"Special Effect"})
       }
@@ -467,70 +475,12 @@ Hooks.on("createChatMessage", async (message) => {
     }
 
     // ── Defense reaction loop ──────────────────────────────────────────────
-    // Skip when attacker is cross-client — the socket handler (handleAttackBoosted)
+    // Skip when attacker is cross-client, or when D30 bonus is pending from GM —
-    // will show the defense dialog and create the comparison message.
+    // the socket handler (handleAttackBoosted) will show the defense dialog and
-    if (defender && defenseRoll < attackRollFinal && isPrimaryController(defender) && !isSpellOrMiracle && !attackerIsCrossClient) {
+    // create the comparison message with the updated attack roll.
+    if (defender && defenseRoll < attackRollFinal && isPrimaryController(defender) && !isSpellOrMiracle && !attackerIsCrossClient && !d30PendingFromGM) {
       while (defenseRoll < attackRollFinal) {
-        const currentGrit = Number(defender.system?.grit?.current) || 0
+        const buttons = LethalFantasyUtils.buildDefenseReactionButtons(defender, { canRerollDefense, shieldData, canShieldReact, canAdHocShield })
-        const currentLuck = Number(defender.system?.luck?.current) || 0
-        const buttons = []
-
-        if (currentGrit > 0) {
-          buttons.push({
-            action: "grit",
-            label: `Spend 1 Grit (+1D6) [${currentGrit} left]`,
-            icon: "fa-solid fa-fist-raised",
-            callback: () => "grit"
-          })
-        }
-
-        if (currentLuck > 0) {
-          buttons.push({
-            action: "luck",
-            label: `Spend 1 Luck (+1D6) [${currentLuck} left]`,
-            icon: "fa-solid fa-clover",
-            callback: () => "luck"
-          })
-        }
-
-        buttons.push({
-          action: "bonusDie",
-          label: "Add bonus die",
-          icon: "fa-solid fa-dice",
-          callback: () => "bonusDie"
-        })
-
-        if (canRerollDefense) {
-          buttons.push({
-            action: "rerollDefense",
-            label: "Re-roll defense (Mulligan)",
-            icon: "fa-solid fa-rotate-right",
-            callback: () => "rerollDefense"
-          })
-        }
-
-        if (canShieldReact) {
-          buttons.push({
-            action: "shieldReact",
-            label: `Roll shield (${shieldData.label})`,
-            icon: "fa-solid fa-shield",
-            callback: () => "shieldReact"
-          })
-        } else if (canAdHocShield) {
-          buttons.push({
-            action: "adHocShield",
-            label: "Roll ad-hoc shield (choose dice + DR)",
-            icon: "fa-solid fa-shield-halved",
-            callback: () => "adHocShield"
-          })
-        }
-
-        buttons.push({
-          action: "continue",
-          label: "Continue (no defense bonus)",
-          icon: "fa-solid fa-forward",
-          callback: () => "continue"
-        })
 
         const dialogContent = await foundry.applications.handlebars.renderTemplate("systems/fvtt-lethal-fantasy/templates/dialogs/defense-reaction.hbs", {
           attackerName,
@@ -557,7 +507,7 @@ Hooks.on("createChatMessage", async (message) => {
         if (choice === "grit") {
           const bonusRoll = await LethalFantasyUtils.rollBonusDie("1d6", defender)
           defenseRoll += bonusRoll
-          await defender.update({ "system.grit.current": currentGrit - 1 })
+          await defender.update({ "system.grit.current": Math.max(0, (Number(defender.system?.grit?.current) || 0) - 1) })
           await createReactionMessage(defender, {type:"grit", actorName:defenderName, resource:"Grit", value:bonusRoll, side:"defense"})
           continue
         }
@@ -565,7 +515,7 @@ Hooks.on("createChatMessage", async (message) => {
         if (choice === "luck") {
           const bonusRoll = await LethalFantasyUtils.rollBonusDie("1d6", defender)
           defenseRoll += bonusRoll
-          await defender.update({ "system.luck.current": currentLuck - 1 })
+          await defender.update({ "system.luck.current": Math.max(0, (Number(defender.system?.luck?.current) || 0) - 1) })
           await createReactionMessage(defender, {type:"luck", actorName:defenderName, resource:"Luck", value:bonusRoll, side:"defense"})
           continue
         }
@@ -663,12 +613,6 @@ Hooks.on("createChatMessage", async (message) => {
           await createReactionMessage(attacker, {type:"d30Bonus", actorName:attackerName, value:d30Result.modifier, side:"attack"})
         }
       }
-      if (d30Result.specialEffect === "auto") {
-        attackRollFinal = defenseRoll + 1 // auto-hit
-        if (canDialog) {
-          await createReactionMessage(attacker, {type:"d30Auto", actorName:attackerName, specialName:d30Result.specialName||"Special Strike", side:"attack"})
-        }
-      }
       if (d30Result.specialEffect === "flag" && canDialog) {
         await createReactionMessage(attacker, {type:"d30Flag", actorName:attackerName, specialName:d30Result.specialName||"Special Effect"})
       }
@@ -685,6 +629,8 @@ Hooks.on("createChatMessage", async (message) => {
         }
       }
       attackD30Processed = true
+      // Track whether D30 actually changed the attack value (for cross-client sync)
+      d30ChangedAttack = (attackRollFinal !== preD30AttackRoll)
       // If D30 boosted attack past defense, restart so defender can react.
       // Only restart when D30 actually changed the outcome (pre-D30 defender was
       // winning or tied, post-D30 defender is losing).
@@ -812,7 +758,7 @@ Hooks.on("createChatMessage", async (message) => {
         // non-GM owner (PC-vs-PC cross-client) — the defender's hook-based
         // processing is suppressed by attackerIsCrossClient, so the socket
         // handler must show the defense dialog instead.
-        if (attackerHandledBonus || attackerHasNonGMOwner) {
+        if (attackerHandledBonus || attackerHasNonGMOwner || d30RequiresSocket) {
           const sData = LethalFantasyUtils.getShieldReactionData(defender)
           game.socket.emit(`system.${SYSTEM.id}`, {
             type: "attackBoosted",
@@ -825,6 +771,7 @@ Hooks.on("createChatMessage", async (message) => {
             damageTier: damageTier || "standard",
             attackD30message,
             defenseD30message,
+            defenseRerollContext,
             hasShield: !!sData,
             shieldLabel: sData?.label || "",
             shieldFormula: sData?.formula || "",
@@ -835,7 +782,8 @@ Hooks.on("createChatMessage", async (message) => {
         return
       }
       // Same client: restart for defender loop if attacker boosted past defense
-      if (defenseRoll < attackRollFinal && attackerHandledBonus) {
+      // (either via Grit/bonus die in the attack reaction loop, or via D30 bonus)
+      if (defenseRoll < attackRollFinal && (attackerHandledBonus || d30ChangedAttack)) {
         mulliganRestart = true
       }
     }
@@ -848,12 +796,16 @@ Hooks.on("createChatMessage", async (message) => {
   //   1. Attacker boosted → attacker's client creates (or socket handler for cross-client)
   //   2. Defender boosted → defender's client creates
   //   3. Nobody boosted → attacker's client (preferred) or defender's client (fallback if same-client)
-  const shouldCreateMessage = attackerHandledBonus
+  //   4. When D30 is pending from GM, the player's client must wait for the socket
+  //      handler — the hook-based values are stale (D30 bonus not applied).
+  const shouldCreateMessage = !d30PendingFromGM && (
+    attackerHandledBonus
     || (!attackerHandledBonus && defenderHandledBonus)
     || (!attackerHandledBonus && !defenderHandledBonus && (
       (isPrimaryController(defender) && !attackerIsCrossClient)
       || isPrimaryController(attacker)
     ))
+  )
 
   if (shouldCreateMessage) {
     log("Creating comparison message", { attackerHandledBonus, defenderHandledBonus, isDefenderOwner: defender.isOwner })
@@ -882,93 +834,51 @@ Hooks.on("createChatMessage", async (message) => {
   }
 })
 
-// Hook: deduct aether when a spell-attack or spell-power roll is posted to chat
+async function _deductResourceOnCast(message, rollTypes, itemType, costFn, resourceField, templateType) {
-Hooks.on("createChatMessage", async (message) => {
+  if (!rollTypes.includes(message.rolls[0]?.options?.rollType)) return
-  if (!["spell-attack", "spell-power"].includes(message.rolls[0]?.options?.rollType)) return
-
   const actorId = message.rolls[0]?.options?.actorId
   if (!actorId) return
   const actor = game.actors.get(actorId)
   if (!actor) return
-
+  if (!isPrimaryController(actor)) return
-  // Only the primary controller (player owner or GM) handles this
-  const activePlayerOwners = game.users.filter(u => u.active && !u.isGM && actor.testUserPermission(u, "OWNER"))
-  const isPrimary = activePlayerOwners.length > 0
-    ? activePlayerOwners[0].id === game.user.id
-    : game.user.isGM
-  if (!isPrimary) return
 
   const rollTarget = message.rolls[0]?.options?.rollTarget
-  const spellId = rollTarget?.id || rollTarget?._id
+  const itemId = rollTarget?.id || rollTarget?._id
-  const spell = spellId ? actor.items.get(spellId) : null
+  const item = itemId ? actor.items.get(itemId) : null
-  if (!spell || spell.type !== "spell") return
+  if (!item || item.type !== itemType) return
 
   const damageTier = message.rolls[0]?.options?.damageTier || "standard"
-  const tierCostMap = { standard: "cost", overpowered: "costOverpowered", overpowered2: "costOverpowered2" }
+  const cost = costFn(item, damageTier)
-  const costField = tierCostMap[damageTier] || "cost"
-  const cost = Number(spell.system?.[costField]) || 0
   if (cost <= 0) return
 
-  const currentAether = Number(actor.system.aetherPoints?.value) || 0
+  const current = Number(foundry.utils.getProperty(actor.system, resourceField)) || 0
-  const newAether = Math.max(0, currentAether - cost)
+  const newValue = Math.max(0, current - cost)
-  await actor.update({ "system.aetherPoints.value": newAether })
+  await actor.update({ [`system.${resourceField}`]: newValue })
 
   const tierLabel = damageTier === "standard" ? "" : ` (${damageTier})`
-  const aetherContent = await foundry.applications.handlebars.renderTemplate("systems/fvtt-lethal-fantasy/templates/chat/reaction-message.hbs", {
+  const content = await foundry.applications.handlebars.renderTemplate("systems/fvtt-lethal-fantasy/templates/chat/reaction-message.hbs", {
-    type: "aetherSpend",
+    type: templateType, actorName: actor.name, spellName: item.name, tierLabel,
-    actorName: actor.name,
+    value: cost, oldValue: current, newValue
-    spellName: spell.name,
-    tierLabel,
-    value: cost,
-    oldValue: currentAether,
-    newValue: newAether
-  })
-  await ChatMessage.create({
-    content: aetherContent,
-    speaker: ChatMessage.getSpeaker({ actor })
-  })
   })
+  await ChatMessage.create({ content, speaker: ChatMessage.getSpeaker({ actor }) })
+}
+
+// Hook: deduct aether when a spell-attack or spell-power roll is posted to chat
+Hooks.on("createChatMessage", (message) => _deductResourceOnCast(message,
+  ["spell-attack", "spell-power"], "spell",
+  (item, tier) => {
+    const m = { standard: "cost", overpowered: "costOverpowered", overpowered2: "costOverpowered2" }
+    return Number(item.system?.[m[tier] || "cost"]) || 0
+  },
+  "aetherPoints.value", "aetherSpend"
+))
 
 // Hook: deduct grace when a miracle-attack or miracle-power roll is posted to chat
-Hooks.on("createChatMessage", async (message) => {
+Hooks.on("createChatMessage", (message) => _deductResourceOnCast(message,
-  if (!["miracle-attack", "miracle-power"].includes(message.rolls[0]?.options?.rollType)) return
+  ["miracle-attack", "miracle-power"], "miracle",
-
+  (item) => Number(item.system?.level) || 0,
-  const actorId = message.rolls[0]?.options?.actorId
+  "divinityPoints.value", "graceSpend"
-  if (!actorId) return
+))
-  const actor = game.actors.get(actorId)
-  if (!actor) return
-
-  const activePlayerOwners = game.users.filter(u => u.active && !u.isGM && actor.testUserPermission(u, "OWNER"))
-  const isPrimary = activePlayerOwners.length > 0
-    ? activePlayerOwners[0].id === game.user.id
-    : game.user.isGM
-  if (!isPrimary) return
-
-  const rollTarget = message.rolls[0]?.options?.rollTarget
-  const miracleId = rollTarget?.id || rollTarget?._id
-  const miracle = miracleId ? actor.items.get(miracleId) : null
-  if (!miracle || miracle.type !== "miracle") return
-
-  const cost = Number(miracle.system?.level) || 0
-  if (cost <= 0) return
-
-  const currentGrace = Number(actor.system.divinityPoints?.value) || 0
-  const newGrace = Math.max(0, currentGrace - cost)
-  await actor.update({ "system.divinityPoints.value": newGrace })
-
-  const graceContent = await foundry.applications.handlebars.renderTemplate("systems/fvtt-lethal-fantasy/templates/chat/reaction-message.hbs", {
-    type: "graceSpend",
-    actorName: actor.name,
-    spellName: miracle.name,
-    value: cost,
-    oldValue: currentGrace,
-    newValue: newGrace
-  })
-  await ChatMessage.create({
-    content: graceContent,
-    speaker: ChatMessage.getSpeaker({ actor })
-  })
-})
 
 // Hook pour appliquer automatiquement les dégâts si une cible est définie
 Hooks.on("createChatMessage", async (message) => {

module/models/equipment.mjs

@@ -7,7 +7,7 @@ export default class LethalFantasyEquipment extends foundry.abstract.TypeDataMod
     const requiredInteger = { required: true, nullable: false, integer: true }
 
     schema.description = new fields.HTMLField({ required: true, textSearch: true })
-    schema.category = new fields.StringField({ required: true, initial: "tinbit", choices: SYSTEM.EQUIPMENT_CATEGORIES })
+    schema.category = new fields.StringField({ required: true, initial: "tinbit", choices: SYSTEM.EQUIPMENT_CATEGORY })
 
     schema.encLoad = new fields.NumberField({ required: true, initial: 0, min: 0 })
     schema.hi = new fields.NumberField({ ...requiredInteger, required: true, initial: 0, min: 0 })

module/utils.mjs

@@ -1,6 +1,6 @@
 import { log, loadCompendiumData, loadCompendium, pushCombatOptions, setHookListeners, registerHandlebarsHelpers, getLethargyDice } from "./utils/helpers.mjs"
-import { hasD30Reroll, processD30BonusDice, _rollD30BonusDie, _buildSpecialLabel, _buildSpecialName } from "./utils/d30.mjs"
+import { hasD30Reroll, processD30BonusDice, _rollD30BonusDie, _buildSpecialName } from "./utils/d30.mjs"
-import { handleSocketEvent, handleAttackerGritOffer, handleAttackBoosted, showDefenseRequest, compareAttackDefense, applyDamage, offerAttackerGritBonus, getCombatBonusDiceChoices, getShieldReactionData, promptCombatBonusDie, promptAdHocShield, rollBonusDie, rerollConfiguredRoll } from "./utils/combat.mjs"
+import { handleSocketEvent, handleAttackerGritOffer, handleAttackBoosted, showDefenseRequest, compareAttackDefense, applyDamage, offerAttackerGritBonus, getCombatBonusDiceChoices, getShieldReactionData, buildDefenseReactionButtons, promptCombatBonusDie, promptAdHocShield, rollBonusDie, rerollConfiguredRoll } from "./utils/combat.mjs"
 
 export { log }
 
@@ -14,7 +14,6 @@ export default class LethalFantasyUtils {
   static hasD30Reroll = hasD30Reroll
   static processD30BonusDice = processD30BonusDice
   static _rollD30BonusDie = _rollD30BonusDie
-  static _buildSpecialLabel = _buildSpecialLabel
   static _buildSpecialName = _buildSpecialName
   static handleSocketEvent = handleSocketEvent
   static handleAttackerGritOffer = handleAttackerGritOffer
@@ -25,6 +24,7 @@ export default class LethalFantasyUtils {
   static offerAttackerGritBonus = offerAttackerGritBonus
   static getCombatBonusDiceChoices = getCombatBonusDiceChoices
   static getShieldReactionData = getShieldReactionData
+  static buildDefenseReactionButtons = buildDefenseReactionButtons
   static promptCombatBonusDie = promptCombatBonusDie
   static promptAdHocShield = promptAdHocShield
   static rollBonusDie = rollBonusDie

module/utils/combat.mjs

@@ -1,6 +1,6 @@
 import { SYSTEM } from "../config/system.mjs"
 import { log } from "./helpers.mjs"
-import { processD30BonusDice } from "./d30.mjs"
+import { processD30BonusDice, hasD30Reroll } from "./d30.mjs"
 
 export async function handleSocketEvent(msg = {}) {
   log(`handleSocketEvent !`, msg)
@@ -100,7 +100,7 @@ export async function handleAttackBoosted(msg) {
     attackerHandledBonus, attackRollFinal, defenseRoll, attackWeaponId, attackRollType, attackRollKey,
     shieldDamageReduction: initialShieldDR,
     d30Bleed, d30DamageMultiplier, d30DrMultiplier,
-    damageTier, attackD30message, defenseD30message,
+    damageTier, attackD30message, defenseD30message, defenseRerollContext,
     hasShield, shieldLabel, shieldFormula, shieldDr, canAdHocShield
   } = msg
 
@@ -124,11 +124,6 @@ export async function handleAttackBoosted(msg) {
         await ChatMessage.create({content: msg, speaker: ChatMessage.getSpeaker({actor: defender})})
       }
     }
-    if (d30Result.specialEffect === "auto") {
-      updatedDefenseRoll = attackRollFinal + 1
-      const msg = await foundry.applications.handlebars.renderTemplate("systems/fvtt-lethal-fantasy/templates/chat/reaction-message.hbs", {type:"d30Auto", actorName:defenderName, specialName:d30Result.specialName || "Special Defense", side:"defense"})
-      await ChatMessage.create({content: msg, speaker: ChatMessage.getSpeaker({actor: defender})})
-    }
     if (d30Result.specialEffect === "flag") {
       const msg = await foundry.applications.handlebars.renderTemplate("systems/fvtt-lethal-fantasy/templates/chat/reaction-message.hbs", {type:"d30Flag", actorName:defenderName, specialName:d30Result.specialName || "Special Effect"})
       await ChatMessage.create({content: msg, speaker: ChatMessage.getSpeaker({actor: defender})})
@@ -143,63 +138,8 @@ export async function handleAttackBoosted(msg) {
   // Show the defense reaction dialog — while-loop for multiple reactions
   if (defender) {
     while (updatedDefenseRoll < attackRollFinal) {
-      const currentGrit = Number(defender.system?.grit?.current) || 0
+      const shieldData = canShieldReact ? { label: shieldLabel, formula: shieldFormula, damageReduction: shieldDr } : null
-      const currentLuck = Number(defender.system?.luck?.current) || 0
+      const buttons = buildDefenseReactionButtons(defender, { canRerollDefense: hasD30Reroll(defenseD30message), shieldData, canShieldReact, canAdHocShield: canAdHoc })
-      const buttons = []
-
-      if (currentGrit > 0) {
-        buttons.push({
-          action: "grit",
-          type: "button",
-          label: `Spend 1 Grit (+1D6) [${currentGrit} left]`,
-          icon: "fa-solid fa-fist-raised",
-          callback: () => "grit"
-        })
-      }
-
-      if (currentLuck > 0) {
-        buttons.push({
-          action: "luck",
-          type: "button",
-          label: `Spend 1 Luck (+1D6) [${currentLuck} left]`,
-          icon: "fa-solid fa-clover",
-          callback: () => "luck"
-        })
-      }
-
-      buttons.push({
-        action: "bonusDie",
-        type: "button",
-        label: "Add bonus die",
-        icon: "fa-solid fa-dice",
-        callback: () => "bonusDie"
-      })
-
-      if (canShieldReact) {
-        buttons.push({
-          action: "shieldReact",
-          type: "button",
-          label: `Roll shield (${shieldLabel})`,
-          icon: "fa-solid fa-shield",
-          callback: () => "shieldReact"
-        })
-      } else if (canAdHoc) {
-        buttons.push({
-          action: "adHocShield",
-          type: "button",
-          label: "Roll ad-hoc shield (choose dice + DR)",
-          icon: "fa-solid fa-shield-halved",
-          callback: () => "adHocShield"
-        })
-      }
-
-      buttons.push({
-        action: "continue",
-        type: "button",
-        label: "Continue (no defense bonus)",
-        icon: "fa-solid fa-forward",
-        callback: () => "continue"
-      })
 
       const choice = await foundry.applications.api.DialogV2.wait({
         window: { title: "Defense reactions — attack boosted" },
@@ -211,7 +151,7 @@ export async function handleAttackBoosted(msg) {
           defenderName,
           defenseRoll: updatedDefenseRoll,
           defenseStatus: "currently has",
-          d30message: null,
+          d30message: defenseD30message || null,
           offerText: "The attack was boosted! Choose how to improve the defense."
         }),
         buttons,
@@ -223,13 +163,13 @@ export async function handleAttackBoosted(msg) {
       if (choice === "grit") {
         const bonusRoll = await rollBonusDie("1d6", defender)
         updatedDefenseRoll += bonusRoll
-        await defender.update({ "system.grit.current": currentGrit - 1 })
+        await defender.update({ "system.grit.current": Math.max(0, (Number(defender.system?.grit?.current) || 0) - 1) })
         const gritRmContent = await foundry.applications.handlebars.renderTemplate("systems/fvtt-lethal-fantasy/templates/chat/reaction-message.hbs", {type:"grit", actorName:defenderName, resource:"Grit", value:bonusRoll, side:"defense"})
         await ChatMessage.create({content: gritRmContent, speaker: ChatMessage.getSpeaker({actor: defender})})
       } else if (choice === "luck") {
         const bonusRoll = await rollBonusDie("1d6", defender)
         updatedDefenseRoll += bonusRoll
-        await defender.update({ "system.luck.current": currentLuck - 1 })
+        await defender.update({ "system.luck.current": Math.max(0, (Number(defender.system?.luck?.current) || 0) - 1) })
         const luckRmContent = await foundry.applications.handlebars.renderTemplate("systems/fvtt-lethal-fantasy/templates/chat/reaction-message.hbs", {type:"luck", actorName:defenderName, resource:"Luck", value:bonusRoll, side:"defense"})
         await ChatMessage.create({content: luckRmContent, speaker: ChatMessage.getSpeaker({actor: defender})})
       } else if (choice === "bonusDie") {
@@ -260,6 +200,44 @@ export async function handleAttackBoosted(msg) {
             speaker: ChatMessage.getSpeaker({ actor: defender })
           })
         }
+      } else if (choice === "rerollDefense" && defenseRerollContext) {
+        const oldDefenseRoll = updatedDefenseRoll
+        const reroll = await rerollConfiguredRoll(defenseRerollContext)
+        if (!reroll) continue
+        updatedDefenseRoll = reroll.options?.rollTotal || reroll.total || oldDefenseRoll
+        let newD30message = reroll.options?.D30message || null
+        const mulliganContent = await foundry.applications.handlebars.renderTemplate("systems/fvtt-lethal-fantasy/templates/chat/reaction-message.hbs", {
+          type: "mulligan",
+          actorName: defenderName,
+          side: "defense",
+          oldRoll: oldDefenseRoll,
+          newRoll: updatedDefenseRoll,
+          diceResults: reroll.options?.diceResults || [],
+          D30result: reroll.options?.D30result,
+          D30message: newD30message
+        })
+        await ChatMessage.create({content: mulliganContent, speaker: ChatMessage.getSpeaker({actor: defender})})
+        // Process new D30 bonus dice from the reroll
+        if (newD30message) {
+          defenseD30message = newD30message
+          const d30Result = await processD30BonusDice(defenseD30message, "defense", null, defender, true)
+          if (d30Result.modifier) {
+            updatedDefenseRoll += d30Result.modifier
+            if (d30Result.modifier > 0) {
+              const rmContent = await foundry.applications.handlebars.renderTemplate("systems/fvtt-lethal-fantasy/templates/chat/reaction-message.hbs", {type:"d30Bonus", actorName:defenderName, value:d30Result.modifier, side:"defense"})
+              await ChatMessage.create({content: rmContent, speaker: ChatMessage.getSpeaker({actor: defender})})
+            }
+          }
+          if (d30Result.specialEffect === "flag") {
+            const rmContent = await foundry.applications.handlebars.renderTemplate("systems/fvtt-lethal-fantasy/templates/chat/reaction-message.hbs", {type:"d30Flag", actorName:defenderName, specialName:d30Result.specialName || "Special Effect"})
+            await ChatMessage.create({content: rmContent, speaker: ChatMessage.getSpeaker({actor: defender})})
+          }
+          if (d30Result.specialEffect === "drMultiplier") {
+            const rmContent = await foundry.applications.handlebars.renderTemplate("systems/fvtt-lethal-fantasy/templates/chat/reaction-message.hbs", {type:"d30DRMultiplier", actorName:defenderName, value:d30Result.multiplier})
+            await ChatMessage.create({content: rmContent, speaker: ChatMessage.getSpeaker({actor: defender})})
+          }
+        }
+        continue
       } else if (choice === "adHocShield" && canAdHoc) {
         const adHoc = await promptAdHocShield(defenderName, attackRollFinal, updatedDefenseRoll)
         if (adHoc) {
@@ -364,6 +342,19 @@ export async function showDefenseRequest(msg) {
 
   const isMonster = defender.type === "monster"
 
+  const _storeNextDefenseData = (opts = {}) => {
+    game.lethalFantasy = game.lethalFantasy || {}
+    game.lethalFantasy.nextDefenseData = {
+      attackerId, attackRoll, attackerName, defenderName,
+      attackWeaponId, attackRollType, attackRollKey,
+      attackD30result, attackD30message, attackRerollContext,
+      damageTier: msg.damageTier,
+      defenderId: defender.id, defenderTokenId,
+      ...(msg.attackNaturalRoll !== undefined && { attackNaturalRoll: msg.attackNaturalRoll }),
+      ...(opts.isRanged !== undefined && { isRanged: opts.isRanged })
+    }
+  }
+
   log(`[LF] showDefenseRequest | attackRollType=${attackRollType} isMonster=${isMonster} defender=${defender?.name}`)
 
   // Spell/miracle attacks use saving throws instead of weapon defense
@@ -398,22 +389,7 @@ export async function showDefenseRequest(msg) {
     if (result) {
       game.lethalFantasy = game.lethalFantasy || {}
       game.lethalFantasy.spellDefense = true // pré-cocher "Save against spell" dans le dialog
-      game.lethalFantasy.nextDefenseData = {
+      _storeNextDefenseData()
-        attackerId,
-        attackRoll,
-        attackerName,
-        defenderName,
-        attackWeaponId,
-        attackRollType,
-        attackRollKey,
-        attackD30result,
-        attackD30message,
-        attackRerollContext,
-        attackNaturalRoll: msg.attackNaturalRoll,
-        damageTier: msg.damageTier,
-        defenderId: defender.id,
-        defenderTokenId
-      }
       if (isMonster) {
         await defender.system.prepareMonsterRoll("save", result)
       } else {
@@ -462,25 +438,7 @@ export async function showDefenseRequest(msg) {
 
     // Si l'utilisateur a validé, lancer le jet de défense
     if (result) {
-      // Stocker temporairement les données pour le hook preCreateChatMessage
+      _storeNextDefenseData({ isRanged: msg.isRanged })
-      game.lethalFantasy = game.lethalFantasy || {}
-      game.lethalFantasy.nextDefenseData = {
-        attackerId,
-        attackRoll,
-        attackerName,
-        defenderName,
-        attackWeaponId,
-        attackRollType,
-        attackRollKey,
-        attackD30result,
-        attackD30message,
-        attackRerollContext,
-        attackNaturalRoll: msg.attackNaturalRoll,
-        damageTier: msg.damageTier,
-        defenderId: defender.id,
-        defenderTokenId,
-        isRanged: msg.isRanged
-      }
 
       await defender.system.prepareMonsterRoll("monster-defense", result)
     }
@@ -497,23 +455,7 @@ export async function showDefenseRequest(msg) {
       actorImage: defender.img,
     })
     if (roll) {
-      game.lethalFantasy = game.lethalFantasy || {}
+      _storeNextDefenseData({ isRanged: true })
-      game.lethalFantasy.nextDefenseData = {
-        attackerId,
-        attackRoll,
-        attackerName,
-        defenderName,
-        attackWeaponId,
-        attackRollType,
-        attackRollKey,
-        attackD30result,
-        attackD30message,
-        attackRerollContext,
-        damageTier: msg.damageTier,
-        defenderId: defender.id,
-        defenderTokenId,
-        isRanged: true
-      }
       await roll.toMessage({}, { messageMode: roll.options.rollMode })
     }
     return
@@ -558,25 +500,7 @@ export async function showDefenseRequest(msg) {
 
   // Si l'utilisateur a validé, lancer le jet de défense
   if (result) {
-    // Stocker temporairement les données pour le hook preCreateChatMessage
+    _storeNextDefenseData({ isRanged: msg.isRanged })
-    game.lethalFantasy = game.lethalFantasy || {}
-    game.lethalFantasy.nextDefenseData = {
-      attackerId,
-      attackRoll,
-      attackerName,
-      defenderName,
-      attackWeaponId,
-      attackRollType,
-      attackRollKey,
-      attackD30result,
-      attackD30message,
-      attackRerollContext,
-      attackNaturalRoll: msg.attackNaturalRoll,
-      damageTier: msg.damageTier,
-      defenderId: defender.id,
-      defenderTokenId,
-      isRanged: msg.isRanged
-    }
 
     log("Storing defense data for character:", defender.id)
 
@@ -584,6 +508,29 @@ export async function showDefenseRequest(msg) {
   }
 }
 
+export function buildDefenseReactionButtons(defender, { canRerollDefense = false, shieldData = null, canShieldReact = false, canAdHocShield = false } = {}) {
+  const currentGrit = Number(defender.system?.grit?.current) || 0
+  const currentLuck = Number(defender.system?.luck?.current) || 0
+  const buttons = []
+  if (currentGrit > 0) {
+    buttons.push({ action: "grit", type: "button", label: `Spend 1 Grit (+1D6) [${currentGrit} left]`, icon: "fa-solid fa-fist-raised", callback: () => "grit" })
+  }
+  if (currentLuck > 0) {
+    buttons.push({ action: "luck", type: "button", label: `Spend 1 Luck (+1D6) [${currentLuck} left]`, icon: "fa-solid fa-clover", callback: () => "luck" })
+  }
+  buttons.push({ action: "bonusDie", type: "button", label: "Add bonus die", icon: "fa-solid fa-dice", callback: () => "bonusDie" })
+  if (canRerollDefense) {
+    buttons.push({ action: "rerollDefense", type: "button", label: "Re-roll defense (Mulligan)", icon: "fa-solid fa-rotate-right", callback: () => "rerollDefense" })
+  }
+  if (canShieldReact && shieldData) {
+    buttons.push({ action: "shieldReact", type: "button", label: `Roll shield (${shieldData.label})`, icon: "fa-solid fa-shield", callback: () => "shieldReact" })
+  } else if (canAdHocShield) {
+    buttons.push({ action: "adHocShield", type: "button", label: "Roll ad-hoc shield (choose dice + DR)", icon: "fa-solid fa-shield-halved", callback: () => "adHocShield" })
+  }
+  buttons.push({ action: "continue", type: "button", label: "Continue (no defense bonus)", icon: "fa-solid fa-forward", callback: () => "continue" })
+  return buttons
+}
+
 export function getCombatBonusDiceChoices() {
   return ["1d4", "1d6", "1d8", "1d10", "1d12", "1d20", "1d20e"]
 }

module/utils/d30.mjs

@@ -28,63 +28,34 @@ export async function processD30BonusDice(d30Message, side, naturalRoll = null,
     return { modifier, specialEffect: null, specialName: null }
   }
 
-  // ── Choice type ── present all options to the player
+  // ── Choice type ── auto-roll bonus dice, alert about special effects
   if (d30Message.type === "choice") {
-    // If we can't show dialogs (wrong client), skip — the primary client
+    // Non-controlling client can't roll dice here — the controlling client
-    // will communicate its choice result via socket. Auto-rolling here
+    // sends the updated values via socket.
-    // would give a different modifier on each client, causing divergence.
     if (!canDialog) {
       return { modifier: 0, specialEffect: null, specialName: null }
     }
 
-    const buttons = d30Message.choices.map(c => {
+    // Auto-roll bonus dice (like d6E on 27 — no dialog)
-      let label
+    const bonusChoice = d30Message.choices.find(c => c.type === "bonus_dice")
-      let icon
+    let modifier = 0
-      if (c.type === "bonus_dice") {
+    if (bonusChoice) {
-        label = `Roll ${c.dice.toUpperCase()} and add to ${side}`
+      modifier = await _rollD30BonusDie(bonusChoice.dice, actor)
-        icon = "fa-solid fa-dice"
-      } else if (c.type === "special_strike") {
-        label = _buildSpecialLabel(c, naturalRoll)
-        icon = "fa-solid fa-star"
-      } else if (c.type === "special_defense") {
-        label = _buildSpecialLabel(c, naturalRoll)
-        icon = "fa-solid fa-shield-halved"
-      } else {
-        label = c.type.replace(/_/g, " ").replace(/\b\w/g, l => l.toUpperCase())
-        icon = "fa-solid fa-question"
-      }
-      return {
-        action: c.type,
-        type: "button",
-        label,
-        icon,
-        callback: () => c
-      }
-    })
-
-    const choice = await foundry.applications.api.DialogV2.wait({
-      window: { title: "D30 Special — Choose Effect" },
-      classes: ["lethalfantasy"],
-      content: await foundry.applications.handlebars.renderTemplate("systems/fvtt-lethal-fantasy/templates/dialogs/d30-special-choice.hbs", {
-        description: d30Message.description
-      }),
-      buttons,
-      rejectClose: false
-    })
-
-    if (!choice) return { modifier: 0, specialEffect: null, specialName: null }
-
-    if (choice.type === "bonus_dice") {
-      const modifier = await _rollD30BonusDie(choice.dice, actor)
-      return { modifier, specialEffect: null, specialName: null }
     }
 
-    if (choice.type === "special_strike" || choice.type === "special_defense") {
+    // Inform about special strike/defense or other effects (informational only)
-      return { modifier: 0, specialEffect: "auto", specialName: _buildSpecialName(choice, naturalRoll) }
+    const specialChoice = d30Message.choices.find(c => c.type === "special_strike" || c.type === "special_defense")
+    if (specialChoice) {
+      return { modifier, specialEffect: "flag", specialName: _buildSpecialName(specialChoice, naturalRoll) }
     }
 
     // Non-standard choice (spell_calamity, etc.) — report it
-    return { modifier: 0, specialEffect: "flag", specialName: choice.type }
+    const nonStandardChoice = d30Message.choices.find(c => c.type !== "bonus_dice")
+    if (nonStandardChoice) {
+      return { modifier, specialEffect: "flag", specialName: _buildSpecialName(nonStandardChoice, naturalRoll) }
+    }
+
+    return { modifier, specialEffect: null, specialName: null }
   }
 
   // ── Combo type (bleed / internal injury) — flag for wound creation
@@ -95,6 +66,11 @@ export async function processD30BonusDice(d30Message, side, naturalRoll = null,
     }
   }
 
+  // ── Bleed type (ranged attacks) — flag for wound creation, same as combo bleed
+  if (d30Message.type === "bleed") {
+    return { modifier: 0, specialEffect: "bleed", specialName: "Bleeding" }
+  }
+
   // ── Damage multiplier type (2x/3x damage before DR)
   if (d30Message.type === "damage_multiplier") {
     return { modifier: 0, specialEffect: "damageMultiplier", specialName: `x${d30Message.multiplier} Damage`, multiplier: d30Message.multiplier }
@@ -130,32 +106,6 @@ export async function _rollD30BonusDie(formula, actor, silent = false) {
   return roll.total
 }
 
-/**
- * Build a human-readable label for a special strike/defense choice in the D30 prompt.
- * @param {Object} specialChoice The choice object with type and options
- * @param {number|null} naturalRoll The natural D20 roll
- * @returns {string} Display label
- */
-export function _buildSpecialLabel(specialChoice, naturalRoll) {
-  if (specialChoice.type === "special_strike") {
-    if (specialChoice.options.includes("lethal")) {
-      if (naturalRoll === 20) return "Lethal Strike (auto-hit)"
-      if (naturalRoll >= 16 && naturalRoll <= 19) return "Vital Strike (auto-hit)"
-      return "Lethal/Vital Strike (auto-hit)"
-    }
-    if (specialChoice.options.includes("vicious")) return "Vicious Strike (auto-hit)"
-    return "Special Strike (auto-hit)"
-  }
-  if (specialChoice.type === "special_defense") {
-    if (specialChoice.options.includes("perfect_spell")) return "Perfect Spell Defense (auto-block)"
-    if (specialChoice.options.includes("flawless")) return "Flawless Defense (auto-block)"
-    if (specialChoice.options.includes("legendary")) return "Legendary Defense (auto-block)"
-    if (specialChoice.options.includes("perfect")) return "Perfect Defense (auto-block)"
-    return "Special Defense (auto-block)"
-  }
-  return "Special Effect"
-}
-
 /**
  * Build the special effect name based on the D30 result and natural roll.
  * @param {Object} specialChoice The choice object with type and options
@@ -179,5 +129,5 @@ export function _buildSpecialName(specialChoice, naturalRoll) {
     if (specialChoice.options.includes("perfect")) return "Perfect Defense"
     return "Special Defense"
   }
-  return "Special Effect"
+  return specialChoice.type.replace(/_/g, " ").replace(/\b\w/g, l => l.toUpperCase())
 }

module/utils/helpers.mjs

@@ -28,83 +28,55 @@ export function setHookListeners() {
     // hud.token / hud.object gives the Token (PlaceableObject), which has .actor.
     const hudActor = hud.token?.actor ?? hud.object?.actor
     if (!hudActor) return
-    // HP Loss Button (existing)
+    const _toggleHudWraps = (prefix) => {
+      const enable = $(html).find(`.${prefix}-wrap`)[0].classList.contains(`${prefix}-hud-disabled`)
+      for (let i = 0; i < 3; i++) {
+        const w = $(html).find(`.${prefix}-wrap`)[i]
+        w.classList.toggle(`${prefix}-hud-active`, enable)
+        w.classList.toggle(`${prefix}-hud-disabled`, !enable)
+      }
+    }
+    const _disableHudWraps = (prefix) => {
+      for (let i = 0; i < 3; i++) {
+        const w = $(html).find(`.${prefix}-wrap`)[i]
+        w.classList.remove(`${prefix}-hud-active`)
+        w.classList.add(`${prefix}-hud-disabled`)
+      }
+    }
+
+    // HP Loss Button
     const lossHPButton = await foundry.applications.handlebars.renderTemplate('systems/fvtt-lethal-fantasy/templates/loss-hp-hud.hbs', {})
     $(html).find('div.left').append(lossHPButton);
     $(html).find('img.lethal-hp-loss-hud').click((event) => {
       event.preventDefault();
-      let hpMenu = $(html).find('.hp-loss-wrap')[0]
+      _toggleHudWraps("hp-loss")
-      if (hpMenu.classList.contains("hp-loss-hud-disabled")) {
-        $(html).find('.hp-loss-wrap')[0].classList.add('hp-loss-hud-active');
-        $(html).find('.hp-loss-wrap')[0].classList.remove('hp-loss-hud-disabled');
-        $(html).find('.hp-loss-wrap')[1].classList.add('hp-loss-hud-active');
-        $(html).find('.hp-loss-wrap')[1].classList.remove('hp-loss-hud-disabled');
-        $(html).find('.hp-loss-wrap')[2].classList.add('hp-loss-hud-active');
-        $(html).find('.hp-loss-wrap')[2].classList.remove('hp-loss-hud-disabled');
-      } else {
-        $(html).find('.hp-loss-wrap')[0].classList.remove('hp-loss-hud-active');
-        $(html).find('.hp-loss-wrap')[0].classList.add('hp-loss-hud-disabled');
-        $(html).find('.hp-loss-wrap')[1].classList.remove('hp-loss-hud-active');
-        $(html).find('.hp-loss-wrap')[1].classList.add('hp-loss-hud-disabled');
-        $(html).find('.hp-loss-wrap')[2].classList.remove('hp-loss-hud-active');
-        $(html).find('.hp-loss-wrap')[2].classList.add('hp-loss-hud-disabled');
-      }
     })
     $(html).find('.loss-hp-hud-click').click(async (event) => {
       event.preventDefault();
-      let hpLoss = event.currentTarget.dataset.hpValue;
+      await hudActor.applyDamage(Number(event.currentTarget.dataset.hpValue));
-      await hudActor.applyDamage(Number(hpLoss));
+      _disableHudWraps("hp-loss")
-        $(html).find('.hp-loss-wrap')[0].classList.remove('hp-loss-hud-active');
-        $(html).find('.hp-loss-wrap')[0].classList.add('hp-loss-hud-disabled');
-        $(html).find('.hp-loss-wrap')[1].classList.remove('hp-loss-hud-active');
-        $(html).find('.hp-loss-wrap')[1].classList.add('hp-loss-hud-disabled');
-        $(html).find('.hp-loss-wrap')[2].classList.remove('hp-loss-hud-active');
-        $(html).find('.hp-loss-wrap')[2].classList.add('hp-loss-hud-disabled');
     })
 
-    // HP Gain Button (new)
+    // HP Gain Button
     const gainHPButton = await foundry.applications.handlebars.renderTemplate('systems/fvtt-lethal-fantasy/templates/gain-hp-hud.hbs', {})
     $(html).find('div.left').append(gainHPButton);
     $(html).find('img.lethal-hp-gain-hud').click((event) => {
       event.preventDefault();
-      let hpMenu = $(html).find('.hp-gain-wrap')[0]
+      _toggleHudWraps("hp-gain")
-      if (hpMenu.classList.contains("hp-gain-hud-disabled")) {
-        $(html).find('.hp-gain-wrap')[0].classList.add('hp-gain-hud-active');
-        $(html).find('.hp-gain-wrap')[0].classList.remove('hp-gain-hud-disabled');
-        $(html).find('.hp-gain-wrap')[1].classList.add('hp-gain-hud-active');
-        $(html).find('.hp-gain-wrap')[1].classList.remove('hp-gain-hud-disabled');
-        $(html).find('.hp-gain-wrap')[2].classList.add('hp-gain-hud-active');
-        $(html).find('.hp-gain-wrap')[2].classList.remove('hp-gain-hud-disabled');
-      } else {
-        $(html).find('.hp-gain-wrap')[0].classList.remove('hp-gain-hud-active');
-        $(html).find('.hp-gain-wrap')[0].classList.add('hp-gain-hud-disabled');
-        $(html).find('.hp-gain-wrap')[1].classList.remove('hp-gain-hud-active');
-        $(html).find('.hp-gain-wrap')[1].classList.add('hp-gain-hud-disabled');
-        $(html).find('.hp-gain-wrap')[2].classList.remove('hp-gain-hud-active');
-        $(html).find('.hp-gain-wrap')[2].classList.add('hp-gain-hud-disabled');
-      }
     })
     $(html).find('.gain-hp-hud-click').click(async (event) => {
       event.preventDefault();
-      let hpGain = event.currentTarget.dataset.hpValue;
+      await hudActor.applyDamage(Number(event.currentTarget.dataset.hpValue));
-      await hudActor.applyDamage(Number(hpGain)); // Positive value to add HP
+      // Clear bleeding wounds on heal
-        // Clear bleeding wounds on heal — regardless of heal amount, any
-        // healing is enough to stop bleeding (field dressing / magic / rest).
       const wounds = foundry.utils.duplicate(hudActor.system.hp.wounds || [])
-        const hadBleeding = wounds.some(w => w.description === "Bleeding")
+      if (wounds.some(w => w.description === "Bleeding")) {
-        if (hadBleeding) {
         await hudActor.update({
           "system.hp.wounds": wounds.map(w =>
             w.description === "Bleeding" ? { value: 0, duration: 0 } : w
           )
         })
       }
-        $(html).find('.hp-gain-wrap')[0].classList.remove('hp-gain-hud-active');
+      _disableHudWraps("hp-gain")
-        $(html).find('.hp-gain-wrap')[0].classList.add('hp-gain-hud-disabled');
-        $(html).find('.hp-gain-wrap')[1].classList.remove('hp-gain-hud-active');
-        $(html).find('.hp-gain-wrap')[1].classList.add('hp-gain-hud-disabled');
-        $(html).find('.hp-gain-wrap')[2].classList.remove('hp-gain-hud-active');
-        $(html).find('.hp-gain-wrap')[2].classList.add('hp-gain-hud-disabled');
     })
 
     // Luck/Grit Buttons

templates/chat/reaction-message.hbs

@@ -21,10 +21,8 @@
     adds <strong>{{formula}}</strong> and rolls <strong>{{value}}</strong> for {{side}}.
   {{else if (equals type "d30Bonus")}}
     gains <strong>+{{value}}</strong> from D30 bonus die for {{side}}.
-  {{else if (equals type "d30Auto")}}
-    uses <strong>{{specialName}}</strong> from D30 — {{#if (equals side "defense")}}defense automatically succeeds!{{else}}attack automatically hits!{{/if}}
   {{else if (equals type "d30Flag")}}
-    D30 — <strong>{{specialName}}</strong> triggered for {{actorName}}!
+    D30 — <strong>{{specialName}}</strong> possible for {{actorName}}!
   {{else if (equals type "d30Bleed")}}
     D30 — <strong>Bleeding/Internal Injury</strong> on hit! Damage past DR will cause a bleeding wound.
   {{else if (equals type "d30DamageMultiplier")}}

templates/dialogs/d30-special-choice.hbs

@@ -1,4 +0,0 @@
-<div class="grit-luck-dialog">
-  <p><strong>D30 result:</strong> {{description}}</p>
-  <p>{{localize "LETHALFANTASY.D30.chooseEffect"}}</p>
-</div>