diff --git a/module/hooks/chat-reaction.mjs b/module/hooks/chat-reaction.mjs
index 24117b0..ff10df5 100644
--- a/module/hooks/chat-reaction.mjs
+++ b/module/hooks/chat-reaction.mjs
@@ -551,16 +551,20 @@ Hooks.on("createChatMessage", async (message) => {
           canRerollDefense = false
           if (!reroll) continue
           defenseRoll = reroll.options?.rollTotal || reroll.total || oldDefenseRoll
-          await createReactionMessage(defender, {
-            type: "mulligan",
-            actorName: defenderName,
-            side: "defense",
-            oldRoll: oldDefenseRoll,
-            newRoll: defenseRoll,
-            diceResults: reroll.options?.diceResults || [],
-            D30result: reroll.options?.D30result,
-            D30message: reroll.options?.D30message
-          })
+          try {
+            await createReactionMessage(defender, {
+              type: "mulligan",
+              actorName: defenderName,
+              side: "defense",
+              oldRoll: oldDefenseRoll,
+              newRoll: defenseRoll,
+              diceResults: reroll.options?.diceResults || [],
+              D30result: reroll.options?.D30result,
+              D30message: reroll.options?.D30message
+            })
+          } catch(e) {
+            console.error("Mulligan message creation failed (non-fatal):", e)
+          }
           // Apply new D30 result on the restart
           if (reroll.options?.D30message) {
             defenseD30message = reroll.options.D30message
@@ -753,16 +757,20 @@ Hooks.on("createChatMessage", async (message) => {
           canRerollAttack = false
           if (!reroll) continue
           attackRollFinal = reroll.options?.rollTotal || reroll.total || oldAttackRoll
-          await createReactionMessage(attacker, {
-            type: "mulligan",
-            actorName: attackerName,
-            side: "attack",
-            oldRoll: oldAttackRoll,
-            newRoll: attackRollFinal,
-            diceResults: reroll.options?.diceResults || [],
-            D30result: reroll.options?.D30result,
-            D30message: reroll.options?.D30message
-          })
+          try {
+            await createReactionMessage(attacker, {
+              type: "mulligan",
+              actorName: attackerName,
+              side: "attack",
+              oldRoll: oldAttackRoll,
+              newRoll: attackRollFinal,
+              diceResults: reroll.options?.diceResults || [],
+              D30result: reroll.options?.D30result,
+              D30message: reroll.options?.D30message
+            })
+          } catch(e) {
+            console.error("Mulligan message creation failed (non-fatal):", e)
+          }
           // Apply new D30 result on the restart
           if (reroll.options?.D30message) {
             attackD30message = reroll.options.D30message
diff --git a/module/utils/combat.mjs b/module/utils/combat.mjs
index d56d847..c1c3582 100644
--- a/module/utils/combat.mjs
+++ b/module/utils/combat.mjs
@@ -206,17 +206,21 @@ export async function handleAttackBoosted(msg) {
         if (!reroll) continue
         updatedDefenseRoll = reroll.options?.rollTotal || reroll.total || oldDefenseRoll
         let newD30message = reroll.options?.D30message || null
-        const mulliganContent = await foundry.applications.handlebars.renderTemplate("systems/fvtt-lethal-fantasy/templates/chat/reaction-message.hbs", {
-          type: "mulligan",
-          actorName: defenderName,
-          side: "defense",
-          oldRoll: oldDefenseRoll,
-          newRoll: updatedDefenseRoll,
-          diceResults: reroll.options?.diceResults || [],
-          D30result: reroll.options?.D30result,
-          D30message: newD30message
-        })
-        await ChatMessage.create({content: mulliganContent, speaker: ChatMessage.getSpeaker({actor: defender})})
+        try {
+          const mulliganContent = await foundry.applications.handlebars.renderTemplate("systems/fvtt-lethal-fantasy/templates/chat/reaction-message.hbs", {
+            type: "mulligan",
+            actorName: defenderName,
+            side: "defense",
+            oldRoll: oldDefenseRoll,
+            newRoll: updatedDefenseRoll,
+            diceResults: reroll.options?.diceResults || [],
+            D30result: reroll.options?.D30result,
+            D30message: newD30message
+          })
+          await ChatMessage.create({content: mulliganContent, speaker: ChatMessage.getSpeaker({actor: defender})})
+        } catch(e) {
+          console.error("Mulligan message creation failed (non-fatal):", e)
+        }
         // Process new D30 bonus dice from the reroll
         if (newD30message) {
           defenseD30message = newD30message